170-174 W Millstream Road, Cream Ridge, NJ 08514 (MLS# 22601419)

170-174 W Millstream Road, Cream Ridge, NJ 08514

$1,500,000
Property Type: Residential Bedrooms: 6 Baths: 3.1 Square Footage: 2,468 Lot Size (sq. ft.): 1,306,800 Status: Active
Current Price: $1,500,000 List Date: 1/15/2026 Last Modified: 1/17/2026

Description

Discover the lifestyle you've been looking for at 170-174 West Millstream Rd—a rare 30-acre preserved farm in beautiful Plumsted Township, perfect for multi-generational living, equestrian use, or those seeking wide-open space with multiple dwellings and flexible use potential. This versatile property features a spacious 4-bedroom, 2-bath split-level main home with a bright sunroom that overlooks the western fields—offering uninterrupted sunset views every evening. Whether you're hosting family or simply enjoying a peaceful morning coffee, the sunroom is a standout space that brings the outdoors in. A separate 2-bedroom, 1.5-bath cottage—currently rented—adds immediate income potential or can serve as an ideal guest house or independent living space for extended family.

Suppliments: For even more flexibility, a former 3-bedroom farmhouse/barn remains on-site with the potential to be rebuilt into a new residence, in-law housing, or custom equestrian facility (buyer to perform due diligence). Horse lovers will appreciate the wide-open fields and the ability to add a pole barn and paddock areaperfect for turnout, training, or future barn and arena development. With 30 acres of preserved farmland, your land is protected from future development while giving you room to expand and tailor the property to your specific needs. Best of all, the property benefits from a current farmland assessmentkeeping your annual property taxes significantly lower than comparable residential parcels. Private well and septic already in place. Just minutes from charming downtown New Egypt and close to major routes for easy access to the Shore or Philly suburbs. Whether you're envisioning a multi-home family compound, equestrian estate, or a blend of both, this property offers the land, layout, and lifestyle to make it happen.

More Information MLS# 22601419

Contract Info

Status: Active List Date: 2026-01-15 List Price: $1,500,000 Current Price: $1,500,000 List Price/SqFt: 607.78 Property Sub-Type: Single Family Residence Sub-Type: Detached

Location

House Number: 170-174 Dir.: W Street Name: Millstream Street Suffix: Road County: Ocean Municipality: Plumsted (PLU) Postal City: Cream Ridge State: NJ Zip Code: 08514 Area/Section: None Complex/Subdivision: None Other Elementary: New Egypt Middle School: New Egypt High School: New Egypt Other High: New Egypt Directions: Rte 539 to West Millstream. Sign at end of driveway; continue down driveway past blue house. Main house will be to your front; cottage to your right. Cottage to be shown on subsequent showings.

General Property Info

Bedrooms: 6 Full Baths: 3 Half Baths: 1 Total Baths: 3.1 Fireplace: Yes # Fireplaces: 1 Apx SqFt: 2468 # Levels: 1 # Units/Bldgs: 3 Apx Year Built: 1970 Garage: Yes # Car Garage: 2 Acreage: 30 Capital Contribution: No HOA: No Pool: No Waterfront: No Waterview: No Farm: Yes

Tax and Legal

Asmnt - Total: 547900 Taxes: 19215 Tax Year: 2025

Property Features

Ownership Type: Fee Simple Style: Split Level Interior: Attic; Bay/Bow Window; French Doors; Recessed Lighting Basement: Crawl Space; Slab Floors: Ceramic Tile; Wood Cooling: Central Air; Heat Pump Heating: Baseboard; Heat Pump; Hot Water; Other Water Heater: Propane Gas; Tankless Exterior: Outbuilding; Patio; Shed Garage: Attached; Workshop/ Workbench Siding: Vinyl Roof: Sloping Parking: Concrete; Driveway Out Buildings: Misc Building Included: Ceiling Fan(s); Dishwasher; Dryer; Fireplace Equipment; Garage Door Opener; Hot Tub; Microwave; Refrigerator; Stove; Washer; Window Treatments; Wood Stove Zoning: Agricultural; Residential Lot Description: Land Locked; Level Water Type: Pond Assessment Status: Assessed Showing: Showing Time

Supplements

For even more flexibility, a former 3-bedroom farmhouse/barn remains on-site with the potential to be rebuilt into a new residence, in-law housing, or custom equestrian facility (buyer to perform due diligence). Horse lovers will appreciate the wide-open fields and the ability to add a pole barn and paddock areaperfect for turnout, training, or future barn and arena development. With 30 acres of preserved farmland, your land is protected from future development while giving you room to expand and tailor the property to your specific needs. Best of all, the property benefits from a current farmland assessmentkeeping your annual property taxes significantly lower than comparable residential parcels. Private well and septic already in place. Just minutes from charming downtown New Egypt and close to major routes for easy access to the Shore or Philly suburbs. Whether you're envisioning a multi-home family compound, equestrian estate, or a blend of both, this property offers the land, layout, and lifestyle to make it happen.
Listing Office: Keller Williams Princeton R.E.
Listing Agent: Christopher Norton
Last Updated: January - 17 - 2026
170-174 W Millstream Road, Cream Ridge, NJ 08514- MLS# 22601419
The data relating to real estate on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of the MLS of the Monmouth Ocean Regional REALTORS®, and site contains live data. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.